| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				8HPX
											 | 
											
				BBS-F003-A
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.431C>T/c.431C>T
											 | 
											
				p.Ser144Phe/p.Ser144Phe
											 | 
											
				MS/MS
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Deveault et al. 2011
											 | 
											
				GB4U
											 | 
											
				64
											 | 
											
				BBS10
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				p.Lys243Ilefs*15/p.Lys243Ilefs*15
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				M
											 | 
											
				0-9
											 | 
											
				4
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				South African Black
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				8HPX
											 | 
											
				BBS-F003-B
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.431C>T/c.431C>T
											 | 
											
				p.Ser144Phe/p.Ser144Phe
											 | 
											
				MS/MS
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Deveault et al. 2011
											 | 
											
				ERE3
											 | 
											
				68
											 | 
											
				BBS10
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				p.Lys243Ilefs*15/p.Lys243Ilefs*15
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				M
											 | 
											
				10-19
											 | 
											
				13
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1!
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				South African Black
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				8HPX
											 | 
											
				BBS-F003-D
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.431C>T/c.431C>T
											 | 
											
				p.Ser144Phe/p.Ser144Phe
											 | 
											
				MS/MS
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				8HPX
											 | 
											
				BBS-F003-E
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.431C>T/c.431C>T
											 | 
											
				p.Ser144Phe/p.Ser144Phe
											 | 
											
				MS/MS
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				L4G5
											 | 
											
				BBS-F004-A
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.480-1700_535+2392del/c.480-1700_535+2392del
											 | 
											
				p.Cys160*/p.Cys160*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				L4G5
											 | 
											
				BBS-F004-B
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.480-1700_535+2392del/c.480-1700_535+2392del
											 | 
											
				p.Cys160*/p.Cys160*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				L4G5
											 | 
											
				BBS-F004-C
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.480-1700_535+2392del/c.480-1700_535+2392del
											 | 
											
				p.Cys160*/p.Cys160*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				L4G5
											 | 
											
				BBS-F004-D
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.480-1700_535+2392del/c.480-1700_535+2392del
											 | 
											
				p.Cys160*/p.Cys160*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				L4G5
											 | 
											
				BBS-F004-E
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.480-1700_535+2392del/c.480-1700_535+2392del
											 | 
											
				p.Cys160*/p.Cys160*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Deveault et al. 2011
											 | 
											
				TGKV
											 | 
											
				52
											 | 
											
				BBS12
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				p.Ser35*/p.Ser35*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				M
											 | 
											
				10-19
											 | 
											
				19
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				Mexican
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				W27X
											 | 
											
				BBS-F018-A
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.480-1700_535+2392del/c.480-1700_535+2392del
											 | 
											
				p.Cys160*/p.Cys160*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				W27X
											 | 
											
				BBS-F018-B
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.480-1700_535+2392del/c.480-1700_535+2392del
											 | 
											
				p.Cys160*/p.Cys160*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Deveault et al. 2011
											 | 
											
				6HZB
											 | 
											
				38
											 | 
											
				BBS12
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				p.Thr501Met/p.Arg525His
											 | 
											
				MS/MS
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				F
											 | 
											
				0-9
											 | 
											
				4
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				Ghanian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				W27X
											 | 
											
				BBS-F018-C
											 | 
											
				BBS3
											 | 
											
				c.480-1700_535+2392del/c.480-1700_535+2392del
											 | 
											
				p.Cys160*/p.Cys160*
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				LEPV
											 | 
											
				BBS-arRP-F026-A
											 | 
											
				BBS4
											 | 
											
				c.157-2A>G/c.157-2A>G
											 | 
											
				p.Ala53Hisfs*2/p.Ala53Hisfs*2
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				LEPV
											 | 
											
				BBS-arRP-F026-B
											 | 
											
				BBS4
											 | 
											
				c.157-2A>G/c.157-2A>G
											 | 
											
				p.Ala53Hisfs*2/p.Ala53Hisfs*2
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				LEPV
											 | 
											
				BBS-arRP-F026-C
											 | 
											
				BBS4
											 | 
											
				c.157-2A>G/c.157-2A>G
											 | 
											
				p.Ala53Hisfs*2/p.Ala53Hisfs*2
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				LEPV
											 | 
											
				BBS-arRP-F026-D
											 | 
											
				BBS4
											 | 
											
				c.157-2A>G/c.157-2A>G
											 | 
											
				p.Ala53Hisfs*2/p.Ala53Hisfs*2
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Kerr et al. 2015
											 | 
											
				KV2V
											 | 
											
				2
											 | 
											
				BBS1
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				p.Met242Argfs*83/p.Met390Arg
											 | 
											
				cLOF/MS
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
											
				F
											 | 
											
				20-39
											 | 
											
				29
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				English/Scottish/German/Iceland
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				Q9A6
											 | 
											
				BBS-F005-A
											 | 
											
				BBS4
											 | 
											
				c.157-2A>G/c.157-2A>G
											 | 
											
				p.Ala53Hisfs*2/p.Ala53Hisfs*2
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Kerr et al. 2015
											 | 
											
				1GW6
											 | 
											
				3a
											 | 
											
				BBS1
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				p.Met390Arg/p.Leu505Profs*52
											 | 
											
				MS/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				F
											 | 
											
				20-39
											 | 
											
				32
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				English/Irish/Scotish
											 | 
											
				 [] 
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Abu-Safieh et al. 2012
											 | 
											
				Q9A6
											 | 
											
				BBS-F005-B
											 | 
											
				BBS4
											 | 
											
				c.157-2A>G/c.157-2A>G
											 | 
											
				p.Ala53Hisfs*2/p.Ala53Hisfs*2
											 | 
											
				cLOF/cLOF
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				Saudi Arabian
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
									
									
											| 
				Shin et al. 2015
											 | 
											
				50Z6
											 | 
											
				II:1
											 | 
											
				BBS7
											 | 
											
				c.103-1G>A/c.728G>A
											 | 
											
				splice/p.Cys243Tyr
											 | 
											
				cLOF/MS
											 | 
											
				
											 | 
											
				M
											 | 
											
				20-39
											 | 
											
				28
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				0
											 | 
											
				1
											 | 
											
				Korean
											 | 
											
				
											 |